Submit a Car for Review

Know a used car that belongs on this list? Tell us about it and we'll evaluate it for inclusion.

What we're looking for

We consider vehicles that score well on reliability (iSeeCars, Consumer Reports), have a strong value proposition versus their segment alternatives, and have enough real-world ownership data to evaluate confidently. We focus on vehicles 2015-2023 in the $8,000–$35,000 range.

How to submit

Email info@island.direct with:

• Year, make, and model
• Why you think it belongs on the list
• Any data sources supporting your recommendation

We review submissions monthly and publish updates to the list quarterly.